Flag Football Tryout Evaluation Form: Free Template
A free, copy-ready flag football tryout evaluation form for rec leagues: one 1-5 scale, eight stations and the evaluation-day rules that keep the draft fair.
What this form is for
Most "tryout evaluation form" templates online are built for soccer or softball, or they are blank form-builder shells. Flag football needs its own rubric: no blocking, no tackling, and a game decided by flag pulling, route running, catching and short, quick throws. This template is the rubric we would hand a volunteer evaluator at a rec league evaluation day. Copy it, print it or rebuild it in your own tool.
It is written for leagues that evaluate once a season so they can draft balanced teams, not for clubs selecting an elite roster. For draft-day rules, see our guide to running a fair snake draft.
The 1-5 scale
Use one scale for every station so scores can be averaged. Tell evaluators to score what they see today, not what they know about a player from last season.
| Score | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 5 | Clearly stands out in this age group |
| 4 | Above average; consistent with few mistakes |
| 3 | Average for the age group |
| 2 | Developing; inconsistent or needs coaching |
| 1 | Just starting out with this skill |
Evaluation form template
Header: Player number (not name), age division, evaluator initials, station, date.
| Station | What to watch | Score (1-5) |
|---|---|---|
| Speed and acceleration | Short sprint from a standing start; first three steps, not only top speed | |
| Agility and change of direction | Cone or shuttle drill; plants and cuts without rounding off or slowing to a stop | |
| Flag pulling | One-on-one in a narrow lane; breaks down, keeps eyes on the hips, pulls without grabbing the jersey | |
| Evading a flag puller | Same drill on offense; uses a move or speed rather than guarding the flags with hands | |
| Catching | Several balls at different heights; catches with hands away from the body and secures the ball | |
| Route running | Short routes such as a slant, out and curl; sharp break, finds the ball on time | |
| Throwing (optional QB station) | Short and medium throws; grip, footwork, accuracy to a stationary target | |
| Coachability | Listens to instructions between reps and applies a correction on the next rep |
Notes field: one line, factual only (for example "left the field after rep 2, re-test"). Leave out comments about families, siblings or which team a player "should" be on.
How to run evaluation day with this form
- Use numbers, not names. Give each player a numbered bib or wristband at check-in. Evaluators score numbers; the league matches numbers to names afterward.
- Put two or more evaluators on each station. Average their scores so one opinion does not set a player's value. Rotate evaluators between stations if you have enough volunteers.
- Keep coaches off their own players. If a coach must evaluate, assign them a station where their own child is scored by someone else.
- Re-test, do not guess. A player who missed a station or was hurt gets a re-test or a blank, never an estimate.
- Weight stations deliberately, or not at all. If you decide that flag pulling matters more than throwing in your youngest division, write that down before evaluation day and apply it to everyone.
- Lock the scores before the draft. Once the draft starts, scores should not change. Share the same averaged list with every coach.
Age-division adjustments
- Youngest divisions: drop the QB station and route running, and score fewer things well. Speed, flag pulling, catching and listening tell you most of what you need.
- Middle divisions: add route running and the optional QB station for any player who wants to try out at quarterback.
- Oldest divisions: keep all eight stations and consider adding a simple read drill for quarterbacks.
From paper forms to an app
Paper works for a small league. The problems start when several evaluators fill out sheets at once and someone has to type every score into a spreadsheet before draft night. ProScout AI runs the same rubric on evaluators' phones and carries the results into a live draft with a lottery, snake order, pick clock and a parity check once the last pick is made. It was built inside Nolensville Youth Football, which runs 90 teams across six age divisions.
Comparing evaluation apps? See our Evalu8 vs TeamGenius vs SkillShark comparison and our SkillShark alternative page. Running an NFL FLAG league? Start with NOVA for NFL FLAG league operators.
Frequently asked questions
What should a flag football tryout evaluate?
Speed, agility, flag pulling, evading a flag puller, catching, route running, throwing for players who want to try quarterback, and coachability. Younger divisions can drop the quarterback and route stations.
How many evaluators should score each player?
At least two per station when you have the volunteers. Averaging their scores keeps one opinion from setting a player's value.
Should evaluators see player names?
No. Score numbered bibs or wristbands and match numbers to names after scoring is locked.
Run your league on the tools built inside one
NOVA was built by the people who run a 90-team NFL FLAG partner league in Nolensville, Tennessee.